Follow Us on Facebook and Instagram

Go shawty, it’s my birthday🥳 To celebrate, we’re serving up Birthday Cake shakes blended with a whole cupcake! You can come party with me today until 8pm! See you soon🧁
Go shawty, it’s my birthday🥳 To celebrate, we’re serving up Birthday Cake shakes blended with a whole cupcake! You can come party with me today until 8pm! See you soon🧁
Anyone have the munchies today? We have you covered! Come grab a scoop of Munchie Madness or one of our 32 super-premium, hand-dipped flavors today🍦 Open til 8, see you soon!
Anyone have the munchies today? We have you covered! Come grab a scoop of Munchie Madness or one of our 32 super-premium, hand-dipped flavors today🍦 Open til 8, see you soon!
What’s shakin’? We’re open ‘til 8 tonight for all of your milkshake wants and needs. See you soon🥤
What’s shakin’? We’re open ‘til 8 tonight for all of your milkshake wants and needs. See you soon🥤
Today’s sidewalk art is brought to you by some of Yummerful’s cutest customers🍦 Open til 7 today, see you soon!
Today’s sidewalk art is brought to you by some of Yummerful’s cutest customers🍦 Open til 7 today, see you soon!
And, we’re back! Please excuse our mess this weekend while we try to offload some of our old equipment😬 ALSO, our Cookie Butter Pie is back! If you’re a cookie butter lover like me, you definitely don’t want to miss out on this on
And, we’re back! Please excuse our mess this weekend while we try to offload some of our old equipment😬 ALSO, our Cookie Butter Pie is back! If you’re a cookie butter lover like me, you definitely don’t want to miss out on this one. Open til 8, see you soon💛
Hey folks! We officially got our new ice cream cabinet this morning! Hopefully we will have it full of some awesome flavors for you guys by next week🤞 Unfortunately, this has left our store in a little bit of disarray. We’ll be opening a litt
Hey folks! We officially got our new ice cream cabinet this morning! Hopefully we will have it full of some awesome flavors for you guys by next week🤞 Unfortunately, this has left our store in a little bit of disarray. We’ll be opening a little late today just to get our shop in order. We will keep you posted and get up and running as fast as we can! Thanks for your patience. We’ll see you soon🍦
This is your sign that you need a scoop of Strawberry Cheesecake🍓 Open til 8, see you soon!
This is your sign that you need a scoop of Strawberry Cheesecake🍓 Open til 8, see you soon!
Happy Eclipse Day🌒 We’re open until 2 today for the eclipse! Come grab a scoop of your favorite out of this world ice cream to pair with your viewing! See you soon🤍✨
Happy Eclipse Day🌒 We’re open until 2 today for the eclipse! Come grab a scoop of your favorite out of this world ice cream to pair with your viewing! See you soon🤍✨
We’re eclipse ready😎 Stop by this weekend and try out something from the Dark Side! Open til 8, see you soon🌒✨
We’re eclipse ready😎 Stop by this weekend and try out something from the Dark Side! Open til 8, see you soon🌒✨
Fresh batch of Cinnamon Roll cookies just dropped😎Open til 8, see you soon!
Fresh batch of Cinnamon Roll cookies just dropped😎Open til 8, see you soon!
We’re oat-ally obsessed with this vegan Blue Moon Oat Cream🌛 Open til 8, come grab a scoop!
We’re oat-ally obsessed with this vegan Blue Moon Oat Cream🌛 Open til 8, come grab a scoop!
Hopping in to let you know we’ll be closed on Easter Sunday! We will return with regular hours next week🐰🐣
Hopping in to let you know we’ll be closed on Easter Sunday! We will return with regular hours next week🐰🐣
Go shawty, it’s my birthday🥳 To celebrate, we’re serving up Birthday Cake shakes blended with a whole cupcake! You can come party with me today until 8pm! See you soon🧁 Anyone have the munchies today? We have you covered! Come grab a scoop of Munchie Madness or one of our 32 super-premium, hand-dipped flavors today🍦 Open til 8, see you soon! What’s shakin’? We’re open ‘til 8 tonight for all of your milkshake wants and needs. See you soon🥤 Today’s sidewalk art is brought to you by some of Yummerful’s cutest customers🍦 Open til 7 today, see you soon! And, we’re back! Please excuse our mess this weekend while we try to offload some of our old equipment😬 ALSO, our Cookie Butter Pie is back! If you’re a cookie butter lover like me, you definitely don’t want to miss out on this on Hey folks! We officially got our new ice cream cabinet this morning! Hopefully we will have it full of some awesome flavors for you guys by next week🤞 Unfortunately, this has left our store in a little bit of disarray. We’ll be opening a litt This is your sign that you need a scoop of Strawberry Cheesecake🍓 Open til 8, see you soon! Happy Eclipse Day🌒 We’re open until 2 today for the eclipse! Come grab a scoop of your favorite out of this world ice cream to pair with your viewing! See you soon🤍✨ We’re eclipse ready😎 Stop by this weekend and try out something from the Dark Side! Open til 8, see you soon🌒✨ Fresh batch of Cinnamon Roll cookies just dropped😎Open til 8, see you soon! We’re oat-ally obsessed with this vegan Blue Moon Oat Cream🌛 Open til 8, come grab a scoop! Hopping in to let you know we’ll be closed on Easter Sunday! We will return with regular hours next week🐰🐣

Best in Madison County 2024

*

Best in Madison County 2024 *

Two Girls, a Dream, and some Ice Cream

Taking over in May 2022, this mom and daughter duo found a passion baking and serving ice cream to the small community of Pendleton.

Easter menu.JPEG
holiday menu pt2.JPEG

What People Are Saying about Yummerful

“Absolutely delicious ice cream and THE BEST COOKIE EVER! The Cinnamon Roll cookies here are amazing! Great staff, great food, fun location in Historic downtown.”

— Ryan E., Google Reviews

“Super love the delicious frozen treats here! The staff are so awesome and enhance the atmosphere amazing well! The building itself bares such a historic light that would give any history buff goosebumps! We highly recommend this place! It's a beautiful hidden gem of Indiana! Already planning on going back very soon!”

— Charles B., Google Reviews

“Great staff, clean facility and amazing ice cream, with a really good selection, plus gluten free options!”

— Paul F., Google Reviews

“We are ice cream snobs and I can say they have the best ice cream ever hands down. Great flavors, excellent customer service, cute place, everything you could imagine. Did I mention the ice cream melts in your mouth it is so creamy? That's why it has taken us 10 times of going before I posted a review because its gone too quick before I get to take a picture. A must stop when in Pendleton. Oh and crazy good shakes! Try them all.”

— Tiffany L., Google Reviews

“Great place in a cute little part of town. The service was very friendly and they had a large variety of unique and cleverly named flavors that were delicious.”

— Melanie H., Google Reviews